Skip to content
ELAGrades 9-12

OUR Odell HSLP

Open Up Resources / Odell Education

Judge anthropic/claude-opus-4-7 · Signal Studio judge (claude-opus-4-7) · 2026-05-28

83

% indicator exact match

Gateways 3/3 Meets

Agreement vs gold

Indicator level — gold and the judge as two raters over the rubric criteria.

Exact match

83.3%

30 indicators vs gold

Weighted κ

0.84

ordinal-weighted agreement

MAE

0.23

lower is better

Signed bias

+0.03

judge over-scores

Attribution

Where the judge diverges, and whether it's signal: per-gateway bias localizes the gap, the confusion matrix shows over- vs under-rating, and the noise floor is the judge's self-agreement across passes (a gap below it isn't trustworthy).

gateway-onen=1190.9%bias +0.09
gateway-threen=1181.8%bias +0.00
gateway-twon=875.0%bias +0.00

Indicator confusion · rows = gold, cols = judge

MeetsPartialDNM
Meets2520
Partial300
DNM000

Diagonal = agreement. Amber = judge rated higher than gold (over-rating).

Gateway rollup

Indicator scores rolled up to EdReports gateway ratings (sequential gating + no-0s cap), gold vs judge.

G1 · Text Quality

28/28 pts

GoldMeets
JudgeMeets
agree

G2 · Building Knowledge

30/32 pts

GoldMeets
JudgeMeets
agree

G3 · Usability

24/25 pts

GoldMeets
JudgeMeets
agree

Gateway-level agreement: exact 100% · κ 1.00 (3 gateways)

Divergences (5)

Indicators where the judge's score differed from gold. Amber = judge under-scored, blue = over-scored.

1l
12
gold Partially Meets Expectations · judge 2 pts
2h
24
gold Partially Meets Expectations · judge 4 pts
3c
12
gold Partially Meets Expectations · judge 2 pts
3b
21
gold Meets Expectations · judge 1 pts
2b
42
gold Meets Expectations · judge 2 pts
Live read from the Signal Studio spine (core-data).