Skip to content

Usability

3n

Indicator 3n

Materials provide extensions and/or opportunities for students to engage with grade-level/course-level mathematics at higher levels of complexity.

The Utah Middle School Math Project·6-8·judged by anthropic/claude-opus-4-7
BorderlineLow confidence

AI proposed

1/2Partially Meetsconf 0.55

There is clear evidence of at least one genuine, purposeful extension that pushes advanced students into higher-complexity investigation of grade-level content rather than just more problems — the labeled 'Extension' in [E4] poses the higher-order question of whether decimal approximation gives every point on the plane for 'the persistent 7th grader.' However, the retrieved materials show mostly grade-level progression narratives and standard-to-standard connections ([E2], [E3], [E8]) rather than a systematic, recurring structure of advanced extensions, so 'multiple opportunities' across the series is only partially demonstrated. This matches the 1-point band: some opportunities for higher-complexity engagement are present, but robust, repeated extension supports are not clearly evidenced.

Your decision

The AI’s score is preserved — your decision is recorded alongside it. Accept / Skip advance to the next flagged indicator.

Evidence Guide· what the rubric asks for · click to expand

Indicator 3n Materials provide extensions and/or opportunities for students to engage with

grade-level/course-level mathematics at higher levels of complexity.

Scoring

2 points

● Materials provide multiple

opportunities for advanced

students to investigate the

grade-level mathematics at a

higher level of complexity.

AND

● No instances of advanced

students doing more problems

than their classmates.

1 point

● Materials provide some

opportunities for advanced

students to investigate the

grade-level mathematics at a

higher level of complexity.

AND

● There are few instances of

advanced students doing more

problems than their classmates.

0 points

● Materials provide few, if any,

opportunities for advanced

students to investigate the

grade-level mathematics at a

higher level of complexity.

OR

● There are many instances of

advanced students doing more

problems than their classmates.

About this indicator:

What is the purpose of this Indicator?

This indicator examines the materials to determine whether the materials provide opportunities for advanced

students to engage in grade-level mathematics at a higher level of complexity.

Indicator 3n Guiding Question:

What opportunities are present for students to engage in learning with grade-level mathematics at higher

levels of complexity?

Are the opportunities that are present purposeful investigations or extensions?

Do the opportunities extend learning of the grade-level content or topic?

Evidence Collection

Review the student materials across the series.

Look for and record evidence to:

● Describe how and where advanced students have opportunities to work at a higher level of complexity

with a standard. Note - this is not students completing additional tasks or more work, but is an extension

of their learning.

● Identify strategies and supports for advanced students exploration of grade-level content at a higher level

of complexity.

● Describe teacher guidance around using grouping strategies with advanced students.

Cluster Meeting

Discuss and answer the following questions to support consensus scoring conversations:

● Where and how do the materials present opportunities specific to extending students' learning of the

grade-level content?

● Where and how do the materials present opportunities to students to engage in grade-level content at a

higher level of complexity?

● What opportunities do students have to develop and apply higher-level thinking?

● What strategies and supports are available for students to engage in grade-level content at a higher level

of complexity?

Gateway 3: Usability

Criterion 3.3 The program includes materials designed for each student’s regular and active

participation in grade-level/grade-band/series content.

Retrieved evidence (12 chunks)

  • E1 · grade-7www.uen.org/emedia/resources/MSM/7-Mathematical-Foundations-Complete.pdfrel 0.63
  • E2 · grade-7www.uen.org/emedia/resources/MSM/7-Mathematical-Foundations-Complete.pdfrel 0.61
  • E3 · grade-7www.uen.org/emedia/resources/MSM/7Ch2Student_Workbook.pdfrel 0.54
  • E4 · grade-7www.uen.org/emedia/resources/MSM/7Ch2Textbook.pdfrel 0.53
  • E5 · grade-7www.uen.org/emedia/resources/MSM/7-Mathematical-Foundations-Complete.pdfrel 0.52
  • E6 · grade-7www.uen.org/emedia/resources/MSM/7-Mathematical-Foundations-Complete.pdfrel 0.51
  • E7 · grade-6www.uen.org/emedia/resources/MSM/6Ch6student.pdfrel 0.48
  • E8 · grade-7www.uen.org/emedia/resources/MSM/7Ch2Textbook.pdfrel 0.48
  • E9 · grade-7www.uen.org/emedia/resources/MSM/7-Mathematical-Foundations-Complete.pdfrel 0.48
  • E10 · grade-7www.uen.org/emedia/resources/MSM/7-Mathematical-Foundations-Complete.pdfrel 0.47
  • E11 · grade-7www.uen.org/emedia/resources/MSM/7-Mathematical-Foundations-Complete.pdfrel 0.47
  • E12 · grade-8www.uen.org/emedia/resources/MSM/8Ch10Student_Workbook.pdfrel 0.47

Evidence is stored as references + retrieval scores (the chunk text isn’t snapshotted); open the source to read the passage in context.